![]() |
|
Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - Printable Version +- Dolphin, the GameCube and Wii emulator - Forums (https://forums.dolphin-emu.org) +-- Forum: Dolphin Emulator Discussion and Support (https://forums.dolphin-emu.org/Forum-dolphin-emulator-discussion-and-support) +--- Forum: General Discussion (https://forums.dolphin-emu.org/Forum-general-discussion) +--- Thread: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. (/Thread-why-asynchronous-audio-should-not-have-been-removed-and-an-idea) |
RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - pauldacheez - 03-30-2014 >people actually using Monster's cables I'd better get out of this thread before it gives me hemorrhoids. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - kinkinkijkin - 03-30-2014 (03-30-2014, 12:16 PM)Sonicadvance1 Wrote:(03-30-2014, 11:51 AM)kinkinkijkin Wrote:(03-30-2014, 11:42 AM)shuffle2 Wrote: Have you tried using Monster cables? There are a few symbols that can be used to denote sarcasm, you know. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - Wally123 - 03-30-2014 (03-30-2014, 11:51 AM)kinkinkijkin Wrote:(03-30-2014, 11:42 AM)shuffle2 Wrote: Have you tried using Monster cables? "Actually, just realized that he might be referring to the usage of an RCA cable for coaxial S/PDIF." Bingo. I grew up around chemistry and metallurgy long enough to know that Monster is full of crap. I am using an S/PDIF digital coaxial cable on my audio connection from my PC to the Stereo Receiver...Part of the stuttering is garbled audio when using a normal 3.5mm headphone jack to connect your speakers or headphones. My guess is that he audio timing is different and my buffer length often has to be set to 64ms in order to compensate for garbled sound when using Asynchronous audio. The reason I do this is because I also use ePSXe to play Final Fantasy 9 and Chrono Cross..two games that take advantage of Sony's DSP capabilities. Without async audio, I get sudden bursts of very loud garbled static as if lighting had somehow struck my speakers. My PC is fully capable of using DTS standard and Dolby Digital 7.1 surround sound without prologic or neo6 if i have it connected to the S/PDIF or HDMI Audio receivers. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - kinkinkijkin - 03-30-2014 Sounds more like an issue with your audio device. If you're using the audio device built in to the motherboard, this would make sense. They tend to be pretty bad, unless liberated by the digital connection. Personally, my motherboard outputs audio at an extremely low volume, and I have to pass it through a makeshift amp (because I don't have a real one at home), and the audio that comes out is also pretty dirty, and occasionally lets out a great crackle that would kill most professional hardware that isn't properly protected, and the ears of people using said professional hardware. To the point that it's wrecking my non-professional, properly-protected hardware rather quickly. So, I wouldn't be surprised if this is a motherboard sound issue. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - Wally123 - 03-30-2014 (03-30-2014, 12:53 PM)kinkinkijkin Wrote: Sounds more like an issue with your audio device. If you're using the audio device built in to the motherboard, this would make sense. They tend to be pretty bad, unless liberated by the digital connection. Personally, my motherboard outputs audio at an extremely low volume, and I have to pass it through a makeshift amp (because I don't have a real one at home), and the audio that comes out is also pretty dirty, and occasionally lets out a great crackle that would kill most professional hardware that isn't properly protected, and the ears of people using said professional hardware. To the point that it's wrecking my non-professional, properly-protected hardware rather quickly. So, I wouldn't be surprised if this is a motherboard sound issue. Can't afford a sound card...The problem does go away with a digital connection :-3 maybe I should run my audio settings through my GTX550ti. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - kinkinkijkin - 03-30-2014 Or you should get a sound system with an optional redirect to headphones. Normally, if audio goes through HDMI, it was still sent through the motherboard audio device. Now, iirc, HDMI is digital audio anyways, so it would have the chance of alleviating your problem, but it can sometimes be more expensive to redirect HDMI audio without invoking the wrath of HDCP than getting a soundcard/replacing your digital audio controller, all of which is less expensive than running down your only audio hardware that you have at home because you're too lazy to do anything about it (my situation). Then again, if you have a screen/TV with a headphone jack, it's entirely okay. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - Wally123 - 03-30-2014 (03-30-2014, 01:35 PM)kinkinkijkin Wrote: Or you should get a sound system with an optional redirect to headphones. Normally, if audio goes through HDMI, it was still sent through the motherboard audio device. Now, iirc, HDMI is digital audio anyways, so it would have the chance of alleviating your problem, but it can sometimes be more expensive to redirect HDMI audio without invoking the wrath of HDCP than getting a soundcard/replacing your digital audio controller, all of which is less expensive than running down your only audio hardware that you have at home because you're too lazy to do anything about it (my situation). Then again, if you have a screen/TV with a headphone jack, it's entirely okay. I have my rig hooked up to a 42 inch Toshiba TV set. "Game Mode" eliminates input lag. I think I'll keep using the current S/PDIF connection until I can afford an audio card. Always helpful to know all this. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - kinkinkijkin - 03-30-2014 HDCP isn't lag. HDCP is stream protection. It's extremely annoying, is part of the HDMI standard (and a few others), and is practically useless for what it's made to do. RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - Gir - 03-30-2014 (03-30-2014, 01:52 PM)Wally123 Wrote:(03-30-2014, 01:35 PM)kinkinkijkin Wrote: Or you should get a sound system with an optional redirect to headphones. Normally, if audio goes through HDMI, it was still sent through the motherboard audio device. Now, iirc, HDMI is digital audio anyways, so it would have the chance of alleviating your problem, but it can sometimes be more expensive to redirect HDMI audio without invoking the wrath of HDCP than getting a soundcard/replacing your digital audio controller, all of which is less expensive than running down your only audio hardware that you have at home because you're too lazy to do anything about it (my situation). Then again, if you have a screen/TV with a headphone jack, it's entirely okay. You best off getting an A/V Receiver rather then a sound card . RE: Why asynchronous audio should not have been removed....and an idea. - Wally123 - 03-30-2014 (03-30-2014, 02:11 PM)Gir Wrote:(03-30-2014, 01:52 PM)Wally123 Wrote:(03-30-2014, 01:35 PM)kinkinkijkin Wrote: Or you should get a sound system with an optional redirect to headphones. Normally, if audio goes through HDMI, it was still sent through the motherboard audio device. Now, iirc, HDMI is digital audio anyways, so it would have the chance of alleviating your problem, but it can sometimes be more expensive to redirect HDMI audio without invoking the wrath of HDCP than getting a soundcard/replacing your digital audio controller, all of which is less expensive than running down your only audio hardware that you have at home because you're too lazy to do anything about it (my situation). Then again, if you have a screen/TV with a headphone jack, it's entirely okay. My PC's audio device...is integrated...My stereo reciever is not the issue. My PC's integrated audio (unfortunately no RealTek) is not the best it could be...Even when I do get decent frame rates, in Dolphin 4.x...I get that odd sudden spike in volume from time to time...and I have my suspicions it's the emulator...Even if I decided to turn off async audio in 3.5...I didn't have that problem. However...I do realize I need a decent sound card...I need that regardless to aleviate my CPU from that burden. I do not have integrated graphics... |