its confusing because your forum ninja skills aren't developed enough young grass hopper. Emulating with dolphin isn't really that hard, for all i know Wind walker is in fact perfect, if it doesn't get the perfect stamp of approval in the relevant thread is because the experienced users don't consider it perfect because some minor graphical errors in game or needs a special fix at some point of the game to go further, you should direct your inquiries to that thread for that matter.
And as StripTheSoul said, some times the original OP doesn't update the thread accordingly.
And as StripTheSoul said, some times the original OP doesn't update the thread accordingly.
My Specs: AMD Phenom II x4 940 3.0ghz - w7/Ubuntu 11.04