I tried everything KHg8m3r recommended, but it did not help. Also, my button threshold is set to 50. I'm confused why I had this problem on two separate computers; is there a possibility this is working as intended? Maybe Dolphin is intentionally adding a buffer for some reason? Could it be the ISO I'm using or the version of Dolphin (which is specifically designed for netplay)? I also have this problem on an older version of Dolphin (3.5-2468); however, I believe that one is also netplay-oriented. I have attached a picture of my controller settings so you can make sure I didn't set it up incorrectly. It's also strange that I only notice this problem on the analog stick. I am certain there is a delay because of my comparison to the game on console, but again, the delay is quite small.
Thanks for your help.
Thanks for your help.