"CarlKenner got banned" complaints thread

[CarlKenner]

I've been working on bug fixes, mostly in the user experience and UI, ready for the 5.0 release.

And I just discovered I've been kicked out of Dolphin, blocked from submitting pull requests or commenting on existing ones, and my pull requests have been closed without comment.

So if you're wondering why your Xbox controllers don't work, controls that are too long to fit their box don't show the full thing in the tooltip, your PAL games aren't labelled PAL, or your user settings are incorrectly overridden with 0 or false, it's because a few developers decided to go on a power trip and ban people.

Fortunately, my installer script changes were accepted before this so your user files won't be deleted and it will show how much disk space dolphin is using when you go to add or remove programs. And my debugger improvements and a fix to an error message were accepted ages ago.

But I guess I won't be fixing anything else in Dolphin any more.

[delroth]

Cool, please keep your political opinions out of our code repository next time.

For people that don't know Carl Kenner, he's the Glovepie author, known for gating download links of his project behind political arguments.

Oh, and FYI, I'm renaming your post from "WARNING: GitHub hijacked, developers blocked!". There is no hijack going on here.

[CarlKenner]

Advocating AGAINST Scientology and homeopathy, as all good people should.

I didn't put any political opinions in your code repository. As I posted before you blocked me:

"It's not a political opinion!!!!!

Brexit already happened. How any of us feel about it is now irrelevant. It's a historical event. And we have to adjust to it, because it changes our use of the flag from a representation of Europe to a controversial political statement. That's just the nature of historical events. It would be like using the USSR flag after the USSR fell. Before the event it just meant that region. After the event, it would be an unintended political statement in support of communism."

And here's a reply to JosJuice which I'm unable to post:

"Where else would you expect the region icon to be used besides on the box and the game disc (which is the thing we're trying to represent in the game list)?

I don't think it's necessary to check other places... but let's do it anyway...

Here's the Game Title Database which I often use for looking up information about game releases and regions: http://www.gametdb.com/Wii/Search

and here's a sample result: http://www.gametdb.com/Wii/RZDP01

I'm not seeing any mention of the European Union, or even Europe, and certainly no EU flags. Just a lot of PAL and the PAL logo.

Or how about another site you might have heard of... apparently there's an emulator known as Dolphin which has a forum... searching the Dolphin forum for PAL returns 129 pages of results. Searching the Dolphin forum for Europe returns 22 pages of results. Searching for European Union returns 2 results (not pages)."

[delroth]

Thanks for proving my point.

[JMC47]

I think this has been said elsewhere - changing the flag to something else is perfectly reasonable for the right reasons. It's just the politically motivated nature of this that spun out of control. I'm sure many people's emotions are running high right now and perhaps it'd be best to cool down.

Overreacting to brexit is happening everywhere right now, it doesn't need to be happening in Dolphin of all things.

Pull-Request for those interested in seeing what happened:
https://github.com/dolphin-emu/dolphin/pull/3926

[CarlKenner]

> Thanks for proving my point.

Reading comprehension isn't your strong suit.

BTW, in case anyone is wondering, the title of this thread is "Github hijacked! Developers banned!"

[CarlKenner]

Oh, and on the topic of editing the icons in the gamelist... if anyone's interested I also changed the platform icons so that all the Virtual Console platforms have their own icons, separate from WiiWare wads. For example, there's an N64 icon, a SNES icon, etc. I haven't done a pull request for that yet though.

Currently my code for that might be a bit slow because I'm trying not to change the format of the game list cache, but if it's in the main branch I could do it more efficiently. So I might have to change it slightly.

[JosJuice]

Regardless of the flag stuff, I really don't see anything wrong with blocking someone who's as hostile as in this comment: https://github.com/dolphin-emu/dolphin/pull/3899#issuecomment-228261135

And "Github hijacked! Developers banned!"? Really? There was no hijack – the people in control are the same as before – and "developers" sounds like it's several developers, not just one person who's made a few PRs.

[derpycat]

Eh. So my Xbox 360 controllers don't work any more?

[JosJuice]

(06-24-2016, 08:58 PM)derpycat Wrote: Eh. So my Xbox 360 controllers don't work any more?

The problem he's mentioning only applies to wireless Xbox controllers. The problem is not new.